|
1. SINGLE-SAMPLE
CLEARENCE
METHODS: IMPORTANCE OF REFERENCE METHOD.
M.
Rehling, S.S. Nielsen
and L.E. Nielsen.
· Dept. of Nuclear Medicine, Aarhus University
Hospital, Skejby Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark.
Five
methods have been published for the measurement of
plasma clearance with the single-injection single-sample technique.
One method uses renal clearence of MAG3 as reference (Bubeck),
four use a multiple-sample plasma clearence method with blood
sampling from 5 to 60-100 min p.i. We speculate whether differences
between the single-sample methods at least in part could be
due to the choice of reference clearance method.
Aim:
To study the importance of reference MAG3 clearance method for
the measurement of the single-injection single-sample MAG3 plasma
clearence.
Material
and Methods: Forthy five patients with GFR 10-132 ml/min
were included. After a single-injection of MAG3, clearance was
assessed from 1) 8 blood samples 5-90 min p.i. (Clp5-90), 2)
16 blood samples 2-300 min p.i. (Clp 2-300), 3 ) renal clearence
2-300 min p.i. (Clr).
Results:
Mean ratio (sem): Clp 5-90/Clr=1.28(0.03), Clp2-300/Clr=1.09(0.02),
and Clp5-90/Clp2-300=1.17(0.01).
Discussion:
Renal clearance of MAG3 was overestimated by 28% by plasma clearance
assessed from blood samples 5-90 min p.i. because of a great
overestimation of the final slope of the plasma curve. There
was a much better agreement when blood sampling was prolonged
until 300 min p.i. . In the upper range of renal function it
has been shown earlier that higher clearance values are obtained
with Russells single-sample method compared with Bubecks method.
The reason seems to be that Russell has used a plasma clearcnce
reference method based on blood samples 5-90 min p.i., while
Bubeck has used renal clearance as reference.
Conclusion: Plasma clearance of MAG3 based on blood samples
5-90 min p.i. overestimates renal clearance. Later blood samples
are needed to obtain an accurate result. Presumably single-sample
plasma clearance methods based on blood samples 5-90 min p.i.
overestimate renal clearance correspondingly.
|