|
|
|
SUMMARY In the D.S.M. IV, classification system of the American Psychiatric Association (1), which is the most used document in investigation and communication in psychiatry, it is stated that the Depressive Disorder affects between 5 and 9% in women and 2 3% of men, while border line personality disorder, correspond to 2% of the general population. Both pathological disorders share dimensions of regulation of affection and control of impulses (2). In these pathologies there are important impaired functions in at least three common systems of neurotransmission with behavioral features such as the cholinergic system, noradrenergic system and serotoninergic systems (3). In this paper an intracomparisson of brain blood flow is reported of a group of patients with Mayor Depression and Borderline Personality, in basal conditions versus activation conditions with the Wisconsin Test, as well an intercomparisson between the results of both pathologies are reported. In this work brain blood flow is quantified by SPECT Tc99m HMPAO evaluating the compromise in areas of the brain cortex, which are part of the three brain separate circuits (4) such as the frontal orbit circuit, the anterior cyngulate and the dorsolateral prefrontal circuit, with its afferences and efferences (5). In the analysis of results we can see a compromise shared in structures linked to motivation, where the anterior cyngulate stands out, while the hipofuncionality induced by the Wisconsin test in borderline patients (P< 0.00005 to the right and< 0.0003 to the left) is more marked than in depressive patients ( P< 0.002 to the right and < 0.003 to the left). The same happens in the area 32 of Brodmann (part of the limbic system), and the area 25 mentioned by Damasio (6) as the area of the "anhedonia" where the compromise exists in both pathologies. There is only in borderline patients a significative compromise of the dorsolateral prefrontal area or executive area induced by the stress of the Wisconsin test. In the other hand in the depressive patients it was detected a more than 50%, more extensive hypoperfusion in the frontal orbit area related to emotions and this is evident (7) in basal conditions as well as with stimulation. |
|||
|
For Eric Kandel (recent Nobel prize in Medicine) (8) in the complex cognitives capacities, the main issue is not any more if the study of the brain localization is useful to understand which are the brain mechanisms by which these functions can be performed. This epistemological approximation orients to the dimensional study of the psychiatric states analyzing the behavior features, emphatizing the study of the brain circuits linked to conduct which act in modular form and facilitation areas of these circuits. It is known (9) that the monoaminergic neural systems modulate the function of the circuits related to the executive capacity and that these same neurotransmissors have been related to aspects of the neurodevelopment to pathologies (10). A recent publication outstands the changes which occurs in the synapses through the neurodevelopment since the second week of life to a fully grown person (Chart I) and suggests that these changes if abnormal, would be responsible of the pathological states observed in patients. There is no doubt that genetics determines in a great amount, what will happen in the future of the individual(11). Nevertheless, the relation with the environment, and in particular with the most significative figures for a person in his infancy, such as the parents (12) (13) (14), influence the synaptic arquitecture. GRAPH 1
In this same line, transcendental changes are known to occur at the age of 18 years (15), mainly in the II layer of pyramidal cells in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, that could be determining the onset of pathologies such as schizophrenia (16) and personality disorders in the early adult life (17). We have thought necessary in this work to maintain a close assessment of cortical areas and the neurotransmission subjacent, as the study of the latter has started to be successful with Neurospect in patients with neurological psychiatric pathologies (Gilles de la Tourette, Parkinson Disease) and could be used in other psychiatric pathologies in the future. This approximation will permit to have an heuristic reading of what happens in the basal areas of the brain in relation to finding of changes in cortical hemodynamia. In both pathologies presented in this work, there would be alterations (18) (19) mainly in two neurotransmission synaptic systems (See Graphic II), and these are linked to the control of impulses and affective demonstrations (20). The serotonynergic neurotransmission system, distributed throughout the brain and whose functionality has been associated to stability of mood, nociception, control of impulses and regulation of circadian cycles would be deregulated permanently in older depressive patients, who show discouragement, impairment of sleeping habits/vigil and in more advanced cases, decontrol and auto aggressive impulses and a diminution of pain and fear, which facilitates the attempts of suicide. On the other hand, the inhibition linked to the depressive patients would be determined by the noradrenergic dysfunction. In the case of borderline patients, the serotonynergic system would be dysfunctional episodically and would present short dystimic periods as intense as the mayor depression. The noradrenergic system also would present a decontrol transforming the impulsive autoaggressive acts in heteroaggressive acts, shown in borderline patients. An explanatory graphic (II) can help to have a better comprehension. GRAPH 2
MODIFIED DE SIEVER AND FRUCHT There are numerous papers which permit to point out dysfunction in borderline patients in specific neurotransmission systems and it can be stated that the noradrenaline "turns on the light", shows people the surrounding and invites them to act; while by serotonin, would indicate sometimes "stop", "don´t continue", if you do so you can have disastrous consequences. The depressive patients as well as the borderline patients have difficulties with these two systems. The third neurotransmission system related to conduct stability (21, 22, 23), is the cholynergic system and borderline patients have demonstrated a clear emotional compromise when using cholynomimetics experimentally (24). Acetylcholine is also associated to cognition (25) and to other important behavioral events (26).
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Sample In a population of patients consulting spontaneously, we took a sample of 249 persons who were diagnosed with psychiatric disorders following D.S.M. IV criteria with the objective of comparing blood brain flows in basal conditions versus activation conditions through the Wisconsin test, in the sample of patients with Borderline Personality Disorder as well as patients with Mayor Depression. The criteria of inclusion were: To fulfill criteria of D.S.M. IV. Interview a significant relative concurring with the diagnosis. Rorschach Test concordant with the referred pathology. In the case of depressive patients it was required also a score in the Hamilton scale for depression > 24 . It was found that 49 patients fulfilled criteria of Borderline Personality Disorder, of which 18 had de Neurospect in basal conditions and 31 in stimulation conditions. It was obtained a group of 40 patients who fulfilled the criteria of Mayor Depressive Disorder, of which 23 had de Neurospect Test in basal conditions and 27 in stimulation conditions. In both groups the patients consuming psychopharmaceuticals were discarded. In the case of antipsychotic drugs it was indicated at least 15 days of suspension and 2 months if these were of deposit. The antidepressives should be suspended at least 20 days before the Spect. The patients addicted to drugs were excluded. Both groups are comparable in sex and age as shown in Tables (I and II). TABLE I SEX AND AGE COMPARISON. PATIENTS WITH MAJOR DEPRESSION AND BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDER DEPRESSION
P>0.05 x2
P>0.05 T de Student BORDERLINE
P >0,05 x2
P >0,05 T de Student
TABLE II SEX AND AGE COMPARISON IN BASAL CONDITIONS. PATIENTS WITH MAJOR DEPRESSION AND BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDER BASAL
P>0.05 Fisher
P>0.05 Mann Whitney SEX AND AGE COMPARISON WISCONSIN TEST. PATIENTS WITH MAJOR DEPRESSION AND BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDER WISCONSIN
P>0.05 Fisher
P>0.05 Mann Whitney These tables demonstrate that both groups are comparable as per sex and age. We analyzed also SPECT in Basal condition and during stimulation with Wisconsin Test. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS The exact Fisher Test was applied to estimate the gender effect in data collected in basal situation and during the test of Wisconsin. It was also used the Student T or the Test of Mann - Whitney, to estimate the age effect. To compare basal results and those obtained with the Wisconsin test, it was used the test of Kruskall - Wallis with correction of Pocock for multiple comparisons in depending samples. The homocedasticity of data was estimated through the test of Bartlet. In the cases the test of Bartlet were not significant, it was used the Student T test to compare both groups. The criteria of statistical meaning is for lower or equal values to 5% (P < 0.05), all the areas which fulfill this criteria, indicate that the change produced between the basal measurement and the measurement obtained during the Wisconsin test, is real (that is, in all the population). In the analysis of the sample of depressive patients it was used the same statistical analysis as in the case of borderline patients. Acquisition of NeuroSPECT HMPAO Tc 99 m. The acquisition of Neurospect in basal conditions and in stimulation through the test of Wisconsin was done according to Protocol published (www.alasbimnioumal.cl/revistas/7/prado.html). Quantification of the Extension of Hypoperfusion in each Brodmann area. In order to define with high reproducibility the exact localization of the hypoperfusion areas observed in the borderline patients a matrix was made with the Corel Draw 8 Program with 24 areas of Brodmann by hemisphere involved in behavioral and language activities based in clinic and experimental conditions (about brain functionality and pathologies by areas). For the confection of this matrix it was used the areas of Brodmann as a reference. These areas are projected automatically by the computer over the images of Neurospect in rostral, right lateral, left lateral and both hemispheric mesial projections of the tridimensional brain images obtained. The projection of this matrix is automatic therefore the reproducibility of the results is 100%. By consensus of the two investigators the extension of each area of Brodmann which appeared hypoperfused and depicted in color blue in the image was estimated; these results were expressed as the percentage of the area of Brodmann that was estimated to be hypoperfused. (Figure I). (Color blue denotes areas that are perfused at more than 2 Standard Deviations below the average perfusion in the brain cortex. Each pixel is normalized to the maximal perfusion in the brain cortex and compared to a normal data base. www.alasbimnjournal.cl/revistas/7/prado.html). FIGURE 1
|
|
The results obtained of the Neurospect in Borderline Personality Disorder patients to whom the test of Wisconsin was applied versus patients in basal conditions, can be evaluated in graphic III, where we present only the results considering the statistical criteria of significance P < 0.05.
In analysis of results with significant differences in brain perfusion measured with Brain SPECT HMPAO Tc 99m, the following areas of Brodmann were abnormal: 24, 28, 32, 40, 44 in the left and right hemisphere and the area defined as M (left and right) and which corresponds to the anterior projection of Dorsolateral Prefrontal cortex. The areas 36 (left), 32, 9 and 46 (right) were affected unilaterally. Following suggestion of Prof. Francisco Aboitiz (Director of Morphology Program, Fac. Of Medicine, U. de Chile) the areas 11 + 12 and 32 + 24 were grouped in order to decrease the possibility of error in the anatomic definition of these zones, the first corresponding to the frontal orbital cortex and the second to the anterior cyngulate plus area 32. In this case de merging of 11 + 12 in Borderline patients presents significance with a P of 0.027 in the right hemisphere exclusively, whereas the grouping of 32 + 24 presents a significance larger in the left (P 0.000109) than in the right (P 0.000197) (graphic V). The same was done in the study of mayor depression and the results can be seen in graphic VI.
GRAPH III
Statistical Significant areas of Brodmann after Activation Borderline Personality Disorder
TABLE III
TABLE IV
GRAPH IV Statistical Significant areas of Brodmann after Activation Mayor Depression The difference between Basal and Wisconsin Activated studies is Statistically Significant in both anterior cyngulate gyri and left area 12 (p<0.009). There is more hypoperfusion during Wisconsin also in Right area 38, right órbito-frontal, area 11 and left area 25 (P<0.05). Of note there was extense BASAL hypoperfusion in area left órbito-frontal and left area 38, that explains the lack of change during Activation.
GRAPH V Statistical Significant areas of Brodmann after Activation Borderline Personality Disorder
GRAPH VI Statistical Significant areas of Brodmann after Activation Mayor Depression
While comparing the grouping of areas 32 + 24 the result was the following:
Left side: Different variables test of Bartlett´s = 5.524 with p-value 0.000109 and Kruskal-Wallis = 12.717 con p-value = 0.000362.: Right side: Different variables test of Bartlett´s = 4.031 with p-value = 0.000107 Kruskal Wallis = 11.142 with p-value = 0.0008. The averages of the significant results in Borderline patients are compared with the significant results in depressive patients in Table V. Then Table VI is presented comparing merged areas 11 + 12+ and 32 + 24 of both groups of patients. TABLE V
TABLE VI
|
|||||||||
|
CONCLUSIONS It is necessary to make some precisions in relation to the investigation, as they influence the conclusions. We have experienced the difficulty in applying questionnaires more connected to clinic ambulatory practice; it is preferred a more general report in relation to dimensional aspects, in this case those referred to impulsivity and affectivity. It is also present the over simplification of the taxonomic aspects (categories) in the moment of making diagnosis (27). For example, it is necessary to have available clinics habituated to taxonomic/dimensional diagnosis. The study confirms information emphasized by literature (28) in relation to difficulty in establishing diagnosis in a more objective way in Borderline patients moderately compensated (who do not require hospitalization). It is of great importance the relatives report (CIE 10). In this case, the same as in patients with organic damage of the frontal lobule (29), it is indispensable a verification with close relatives. It is also important to point out that many of the behavioral manifestations in patients with organic frontal damage are shared, though in less intensity, with the patients with Borderline personality disorder, this suggests that both categories of pathologies share similar anatomo-functional substrates. In studying brain perfusion of borderline patients in basal conditions versus stimulation conditions through the test of Wisconsin, it is evident a significant change in the blood brain flow, mostly in the areas we expected to perform abnormally. That is, in the areas mentioned by literature, linked to conduct and also in this work hypothesis. The more sensible areas discussed in this paper are part of two of the three cortical/subcortical circuits reviewed previously www.alasbimnjournal.cl/revistas/7/prado.html April 2000. The Dorsolateral Prefrontal circuit related to executive capacity and the anterior cyngulate circuit related to motivation. No significant changes were observed in the frontal-orbital area related to affectivity, while analyzing areas 11 and 12 separately; but when analyzing them in the merged modality they show significant changes in the right hemisphere. While using comparatively samples of patients with Mayor Depression it was found in both groups significative differences in cortical perfusion corresponding to the anterior cyngulate circuit, being much more pronounced in borderline patients. However, in Major Depression in the orbital- frontal area it is evident that there is an extension of the hypoperfusion larger than 50% (corresponding to the circuit of the same name, related to affectivity), in basal conditions as well as in conditions of stimulation bilaterally. This fact was not observed in the sample of borderline patients, where the extension of the hypoperfusion was not larger than 25% in average. In the group of depressive patients (different from the borderline patients) there were no changes in the cortex corresponding to the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (executive capacity). As this is an initial study, it is important to protect the real image/area reproducibility; for this we have undertaken to merge the adjacent areas 11 and 12 (orbital- frontal) and 32 + 24 (anterior cyngulate + area 32). By this mechanism in the borderline patients there is persistence of the significance of the merged areas 32 + 24 versus area 24 by itself (of P 0.0003 and 0.000109 respectively) in the left hemisphere and (P 0.00005 to 0.000197) in right hemisphere. In the depressive patients, the statistical significance was less (from P 0.003 to 0.008 in left hemisphere and from P 0.002 to P 0.0257 in the right hemisphere). While merging areas 11 and 12, in the orbital- frontal area in borderline patients, is significative with P 0.021 to the right and P 0.018 to the left. The fact that the area 11 by itself is not significative suggests that the orbital-frontal change is produced at the expenses of area 12. In depressive patients it is always expressed by more than 50% of hypoperfusion in the left hemisphere frontal orbit area (areas 11 + 12) decreasing the hypoperfusion in right hemisphere to 45% average, in basal conditions as well as in stimulation conditions with the test of Wisconsin. In the depressive patients while evaluating area 11 (right to left) the flow is evenly decreased (more than 50%) in basal conditions as well as in stimulation. If area 12 is added de decrease already mentioned is only in left frontal orbit area. Other areas which are sensible in the right hemisphere in borderline patients to the stimulation through the test of Wisconsin, are the right afferent area of the dorsolateral prefrontal area with a P 0.005 and the area 40, 32, 44, 46 and 9 with a P 0.05. On the other hand, in the left side the area 40 shows larger significance than to right, P 0.005 and area 44 P 0.05 same than the right. One can see also a left impairement of area 25 of Brodmann or subgenual P 0.005, defined by Damasio as the area that being dysfunctional would be responsible of anhedonia. Also the left areas 44, 36 and 28 show a compromise with a P 0.05 On the other hand the analysis of other areas in depressive patients show significance at the area 28 of Brodmann P 0.04 and the 38 P 0.03 to the right. Analysis of the Significance of Functional Changes in Different Cerebral Areas as a Consequence of Activation with the Wisconsin test. Area M. Corresponds to the anterior projection of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex which is related to superior intelligence. Normally this area is stimulated increasing brain blood flow during the activation. (www.alasbimnjournal.cl/revistas/3/villanuevaa.htm). In these experiments we observe a paradoxical diminution of cerebral blood flow when we compare with Neurospect gathered in basal conditions namely P 0.003 in right hemisphere and P 0.042 in left hemisphere. One of the behavioral characteristics described in patients with borderline personality disorder are significant variations in social behaviors, occupational or interrelation activities. These disruptive behaviors are associated frequently to frustration felt by the patient in front of personal events or external events sometimes of minor significance that lead however to a record full of disadaptative performances. This fact is observed even in patients with high intellectual coefficient that during the moment of crisis looses its significance, for O. Kernberg, the patient "derails". Another difficulty of borderline patients is their incapacity of establishing priorities in their daily life. This presupposes an adequate perception of emotional details and their evaluation within a structured totality. In periods of stress during which affectivity could be more involved, their responsiveness is more unpredictable. This difficulty to assess the emotional weight for adaptative purposes, is more severe and permanent in schizophrenia. In schizophrenia the dorsolateral prefrontal area, in particular area 46, diminishes cerebral blood flow during cerebral activation (35) by means of the Wisconsin test. In borderline patients we observe similar diminution, but we think with a lesser intensity than the reported for schizophrenia., this however is clearly significant in the borderline patients. The difficulties of flexibility of behaviors or to keep stable patterns of behavior seen in borderline patients, is predicted by D.S.M. IV only to start improving spontaneously on or about 40 years of age. Borderline patients have a poor memory of information during periods of dysfunctional periods. These week memories of self affecting circumstances provoked by their behavior is an explanation of their incapability of avoiding repeating these situations, thus the patient has not learned from experience. From this information we may understand that borderline patients have a poor memory for information for recent or remote information in particularly situations that are damaging repeatedly. Anna Freud (36) explains these facts like mechanisms of defense like negation or intelectualization and Gazzaniga (37) would state that human beings process 98% of perceptions automatically, the left hemisphere being always ready to explain the facts from its limited observation angle influenced by reports of inaccurate memories. Both investigators coincide in stating the difficulty of changing opinion that this patients have or the inflexibilities of the judgement with regards to perceived stimuli. This condition is very evident in the borderline patients which show in their characteristic pattern of confrontation and polarization in their affective relationships, thus there is a tendency of overvaluing to the extreme the other subject (D.S.M. IV). This phenomenon also has a tendency to attenuate itself after the age of 45. At this age the right hemisphere becomes more dominant, there is more common sense (such will define the capability of detecting social and environmental clues and of an adaptative response) Also there is a stronger and better capacity to structure in a globality. It is necessary to emphasize that all these features correspond functionally to the dorso lateral prefrontal circuit. We have reported in previous publications (www.alasbimnjournal.cl/revistas/3/pradoia.htm) that the conducts of utilization of the environment and the conducts of imitation are clearly stated in the features of DSM IV and refers to a loss of control in different activities that are potentially conducive to self inflicting damage such as uncontrolled gambling, reckless driving, drugs consumptions or lack of control of appetite and lack of control in spending. In this circuit we locate the capability to perform tasks as required by complex attention and guidance of conduct with intelligent thinking. In these patients a dysfunction in this circuitry would difficult this capability intermittently. The dorsolateral prefrontal cortex has been related to superior intelligence, this concept refers to the way the intellectual coefficient is utilized. Weschlers report states that intelligence is the total capacity, global or aggregated (corresponds to the product of various abilities), in order to think rationally, of performing with a purpose and struggle effectively with the environment. In conditions of stress this area mysfunctions transiently in border line patients. In normal individuals this area has an increase of cerebral blood flow during the activation with an approximate increase of 15% of blood flow, as measured with Xe133. In this case we observe a paradoxical diminution of blood flow in comparison with Spect recorded in basal conditions in the anterior projection (Area M). In the lateral projection there is a diminution in Area 46 right (P 0.046 and area 9 right (P 0.016). The same response occurs in patients who suffer schizophrenia (39) where the principal area affected is area 46 of Brodmann. Area 25 Border line patients show a more marked diminution of cerebral blood flow (p 0.006), during activation of the area of the area 25 of Brodmann. This area corresponds to the subgenual region which according to Damasio, is responsible in a dysfunctional state of loss of pleasure, of anhedonia and negative anticipation. The area 25 allows the evaluation of facts of life in terms of reward and punishment. In this study area 25 appears affected only in the left hemisphere. Concerning the displeasure that would express itself in this area, it is important to remember that this is a frequent response in borderline patients facing their mistakes in the Wisconsin test as a displeasure feeling that is recorded during the two minutes of window of NeuroSPECT as a diminution of blood flow or extension of the magnitude of the area hypoperfused. In every day life these patients would present a tendency to displeasure or a poor tolerance to frustration induced by unexpected changes in plans or an increase on the demands on themselves.
Anterior Cyngulate and Area 32 In borderline personality disorder these areas are clearly more sensitive with a marked diminution of blood flow during activation and a P 0.00005 in the right hemisphere and 0.0003 in the left hemisphere and for Area 32 0.031 in the right and 0.006 in the left hemisphere respectively (Graphic III). GRAPH 3
Both areas, anterior cyngulate and Area 32 correspond to the area of cortex that is located in front of the corpus callosum in its anterior and dorsal areas. The dorsal area of the anterior cyngulate gyrus is related to cognitive motivation, while the ventral area is related to general motivation in emotions (both areas are constituents of the limbic system). The cerebral blood flow of this area shows a clear difference when we compare basal versus activation studies: the demand of the Wisconsin test of changing of strategies is accompanied by a diminution of blood flow and function in conditions of frustration. It is very probable that the dysphoria presented by these patients at that particular time could inactivate temporarily these structure (Area 24 and 32) and indirectly the area dorsolateral prefrontal due to emotional interferences because in basal conditions this same type of patients do not show a significant compromise or this type of function in this location. It is of interest to support the findings of this study through the correlation with typical maneuvers of the borderline patients that can be related with neuropsychological aspects. The loss of motivation of these patients that is manifested by changes of demand of the environment (D.SM.IV) can be related to an episodic mutism and apathy as a response to the demands of a task. Of note there are reports stating the dysfunction of the anterior cyngulate gyrus in experiences of psychic emptiness (www.alasbimnjournal.cl/revistas/3/pradoia.htm) this is an emotional state that could precede acts of hetero or auto inflicting damage . It is possible to notice in these self inductive lesions of behaviors the need of a diminution of fear (a low serotoninergic stimulation) and a increase of the pain threshold that facilitate this type of behavior. The anterior cyngulate gyrus has a high density of opiate receptors (41) and also an extensive serotonynergic innervation. Orbito-Frontal Area In borderline patients there are no significant changes in area 11, however area 12 in this same region shows an extension of hypoperfusion during the activation in the right hemisphere, while in mayor depressive patients these changes of increase of extension of hypoperfusion in the órbito-frontal lobule are stable and independent of the Wisconsin stressor and occur in both hemispheres. The findings in the patients with borderline personality disorder may be related to irritability, impropriety, euphoria, impulsivity, unwarranted familiarity and abnormalities of mood. This occurs in patients with border line personality disorder intermittently and related to situations of stress, in this study during the Wisconsin test. Areas 28 36 and 40 44 Among these areas 40 and 44 are related to language and areas 28 and 36 are related to codification of episodic memory. The areas related to language and memory could correspond to areas of the cortex that facilitate some of the behaviors that we have studied and this could by a hypothesis for future research. Area 38 of Brodmann This area is hypoperfused in basal conditions and during activation with the Wisconsin test and therefore does not present significant changes with the activation procedures (extension of hypoperfusion 47%) and in depression (extension of hypoperfusion 58%). Area 38 is a segment of the temporal pole and facilitates the interaction of cognition and emotional aspects. In post mortem studies of suicides there is a low concentration of serotonynergic neurotransmission of that site. Of note is the finding of a loss of function of area 38 in both pathologies, that invite a study of aspects related to control of impulses and affective instability. Therefore, in this hemodynamic cerebral study we have reported by means of cortical activation, that NeuroSPECT demonstrates in mayor depression and borderline personality disorder regional differences that are characteristically significant during the Wisconsin test. At the same time it demonstrates the existence of cortical areas that facilitate function in a nonspecific way and that participates in both processes. |
|
|||